← All posts

A blank field does not say why

Some of the empty fields in your catalogue are decisions. A lamp has no fabric composition; a one-size scarf has no size chart; a product that has never been discounted has no compare-at price. Others are things nobody got round to. Both render as the same blank, and every tool that offers to improve your listing will hand you one list containing both — sorted by nothing.

Published — written and checked by hand.

Open any tool that scores a product listing and it will give you a list of what to fill in. It built that list the only way it can: by taking the fields the format allows, checking which ones you have filled, and reporting the rest. That is a useful list. It is also a list with two completely different kinds of thing on it, and no column that says which is which.

Two blanks that look identical

A field in your catalogue can be empty for two reasons. Either the fact does not exist — the product genuinely has no second colourway, no expiry date, no recommended age range — or the fact exists and nobody has typed it. The first is a finished decision. The second is unfinished work.

From outside there is no difference. An empty field is an empty field; it carries no note about how it got that way. So anything reading your catalogue from outside — a marketplace completeness meter, a shopping-feed validator, an SEO audit, a competitor comparison — reports both as a gap, because for that reader they are the same observation.

This is not a flaw in those tools. There is nothing else they could do. The information that distinguishes the two cases was never written down anywhere they can see.

What goes wrong when you work the list top to bottom

The damage is not wasted effort. It is that filling in a deliberately-empty field means producing a value that was not there to be had, and the easiest value to produce is one you make up:

  • A compare-at price on something that has never been on sale. The field wants a number, and the number implies a discount that never happened.
  • A material or composition on a product you buy finished and do not have a spec sheet for. A plausible guess here is a claim a customer can hold you to.
  • A country of origin you are fairly sure about. Fairly sure is a different thing from documented, and this is a field people read as documented.
  • A size chart on a one-size item, invented so the chart is not missing. Now there are measurements, and they are the only ones anybody will check against.
  • Padding a description to clear a length threshold. The threshold is met and the description is worse, because the sentences you added were chosen for their length.
  • A care instruction copied from a similar product. It is usually right, and the time it is wrong, it is wrong in the laundry.

Every one of those is a seller acting in good faith on a list that asked them to be complete and never asked them to be sure. The field was blank because the fact was unknown; filling it does not make the fact known, it just stops the blank being visible.

Sort the list before you work it

The habit is small: before filling anything, split the list in two. For each item, ask whether you are retrieving a fact or producing one. Retrieving means it exists somewhere — a supplier sheet, an invoice, a tape measure, the product in your hand. Producing means you are about to decide what it says.

Everything in the retrieving pile is real work and worth doing; it is usually most of the list. Everything in the producing pile stops there. Those blanks are correct and should stay blank.

Then write the decision down

The second half is what keeps the sorting from being repeated forever. A blank you have decided about looks exactly like a blank you have not, which means next month you — or whoever is doing this next — will sort it again from scratch, and will not have the reasoning you had today. Possibly they will fill it in.

So record the decision somewhere it will be found by the person facing the same list: a note on the product, a line in whatever document holds your conventions, a comment wherever your templates live. It does not need to be formal. It needs to say which blanks are closed and why, so that an absence has a reason attached to it the next time something points at it.

This is also the answer to a gap analysis against a competitor. Comparing your listings to a rival's produces a list of fields they fill and you do not, and it is a genuinely useful way to find things you have missed. But it has the same blind spot, with a sharper edge: some of what they publish, you have reasons not to. Their warehouse address is on their site because they have a warehouse. Their founder's name is on their about page because they chose to put it there. Reading a competitor's filled field as your missing one assumes you are the same business with less work done.

Our own case, since it is the reason this is written down

We compare our own pages against competitors' regularly, including the machine-readable description of who publishes this site. The last comparison produced a list of things several of them declare and we do not. Three were real omissions — facts already written in plain English in our own terms and privacy pages, simply never stated in a form a machine could read. Those are now stated, and a check in our build fails if they go missing.

Two of the others were not omissions at all. They are properties we had previously decided not to publish, for recorded reasons, and the comparison had no way to know that — it saw the same shape of hole in all five. The fix was not to fill them in. It was to add a check that fails if anybody ever does, so the decision is enforced rather than remembered, and the next comparison runs into a wall with an explanation written on it instead of a blank that looks like an invitation.

That is the whole of it. Absence is not self-documenting. If a blank in your catalogue is a decision, it is worth one sentence somewhere, because without that sentence it is indistinguishable from a job nobody finished — and the tools that will ask you about it are very persuasive and completely blind.

Lights up

Read enough? Watch your own product.

One photo in — a cinematic product video and a full set of marketing photos out. Your first one is free.

Free preview · no cardSee it filmed — free