← All posts

A mention is not a listing

Somewhere in your shop is something you genuinely sell that no page is about. Gift wrapping named in a FAQ answer. Engraving mentioned halfway down a product description. A size you stock but never listed. Each one is real, each one is written down, and a customer searching for exactly that thing arrives nowhere — because a search result points at a page, never at a sentence.

Published — written and checked by hand.

We found this on our own site, which is the only reason this post is specific rather than preachy. We offer a tool that turns any photograph into a white-background packshot, another that cuts the background away entirely, and a run that photographs up to fifty products in one go. All three were written up. The packshot was described on sixteen different pages. And not one page on the site was about it — the words lived as a subheading inside an answer to a different question, so somebody typing "white background product photo" met either an essay or nothing at all.

Two lists that never get compared

Every shop keeps two inventories without noticing. The first is what you actually offer: the products, the variants, the sizes, the services, the things you will do if asked. The second is what you have a page for. New things join the first list the moment you start doing them, and join the second only when somebody sits down and makes a page. Nothing reconciles them. So the gap fills up, and it fills up specifically with the things that were easy to mention in passing — which are usually the small, high-intent extras that a customer would have searched for by name.

The reason that costs you something is structural rather than algorithmic. A search result, a shared link, a bookmark and a citation all point at a page. None of them can point at the fourth paragraph of a page about something else. So a sentence, however true and however well written, is not reachable by anybody who does not already have the page it sits in — and the people searching for that exact thing are precisely the people who do not have it yet.

The things most often stranded in a paragraph

It is worth going and looking, because the pattern is consistent across shops:

  • Services mentioned in an FAQ answer. Gift wrapping, engraving, resizing, rush delivery, repairs. Someone searching "engraving" plus your category is a ready buyer and will never see a line inside your returns answer.
  • Variants named in a product description. "Also available in brass." The brass version has demand of its own, and no address.
  • Materials and care instructions. "Hand-forged", "food-safe", "machine washable" — each is a search somebody runs before buying, and each tends to live as a clause.
  • Who it is for. A line saying "popular with wedding photographers" is doing the work of a page, badly, for an audience that would have searched for themselves by name.
  • Anything you added recently. The newest thing you offer is the most likely to exist only as a sentence, because the sentence was the fast way to ship it.

The test is one question asked of each line: would somebody type these words into a search box? Not "is this true" and not "is this mentioned" — both of those will be yes, which is exactly why mentioning feels like it was enough. The question is whether the words are a thing people go looking for.

What to do about the ones that matter

Not all of them deserve a page, and giving a page to every clause would leave you with a hundred thin ones competing with each other. The ones that earn a page have two properties: somebody searches for them by name, and you can say more than two sentences about them that a buyer actually needs. Gift wrapping with three options, a price and a cut-off date is a page. "Gift wrapping available" is a sentence, and should stay one.

When you do promote one, move the depth rather than copying it. This is the part people get wrong: they write the new page and leave the original paragraph in place, and now two addresses carry the same words and neither is clearly the one to send anybody to. Cut the original back to a sentence that names the thing and links to it. One deep explanation, one address, one place to keep it current.

There is a version of this for photographs too, which is that a set of near-identical pictures is not more information than one picture — the same confusion of volume with coverage. Fifty products should look like one shop, and fifty pages should each be about something different.

Why this is cheap work

Because you have already done the hard part. The thing exists, you know how it works, and you have written a sentence about it that is true — which means the page is an expansion of something you already understand rather than a decision you still have to make. In our case the words had been sitting in the right building for weeks; they just did not have a door onto the street.

The habit worth keeping is a small one. When you start offering something, or stop, the question is not only whether the site still says something true about it — it is whether there is somewhere to send a person who wants that one thing. Those are different questions, and the first one passing is what stops anybody asking the second. It is the same discipline as deciding the order of your product images once you accept that a listing is a sequence, not a gallery: you are choosing what each slot is for, rather than adding another thing to a pile.

Lights up

Read enough? Watch your own product.

One photo in — a cinematic product video and a full set of marketing photos out. Your first one is free.

Free preview · no cardSee it filmed — free